As a pre-med, is it better to be a phlebotomist, scribe, or CNA?
As a premed student, you may be wondering whether it's better to work as a phlebotomist, medical scribe, or certified nursing assistant (CNA). Each of these roles provides unique clinical experience, but which is the best choice when preparing for medical school? Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of each role, updated with the latest insights for 2025.
Decide What You Want to Do with Your Life
Choosing the right career path can be overwhelming, but your journey as a premed student can provide valuable insights into what kind of future you want. Exploring different medical specialties through hands-on exposure allows you to gain deeper knowledge of the areas that interest you most. This clinical experience not only helps you make informed decisions about your career but also gives you a competitive edge over others who may not have explored medicine as deeply. Even if you're unsure about becoming a doctor, the clinical experience you gain as a premed student can still be invaluable in making decisions about your future career.
Why Premeds Should Consider Phlebotomy
Phlebotomy can be an excellent option for premed students, as it allows you to gain clinical experience that is recognized by many medical schools. As a phlebotomist, you'll be trained in blood collection for diagnostic tests, a crucial task in patient care. This hands-on experience provides you with an in-depth understanding of diagnostic processes while helping you build rapport with patients. The skills you acquire as a phlebotomist are highly transferable and can set you apart on medical school applications. Another excellent way to gain valuable experience is medical scribing—check out why premeds should consider medical scribing for success to enhance your med school application further.
Phlebotomy is widely accepted as clinical experience by medical schools, making it a great way to meet the requirements for med school applications. Not only does this role provide direct patient care, but it also allows you to observe how diagnostic tests play a critical role in medical treatment, which can offer invaluable insight into your future career. Despite its benefits, some premeds wonder whether phlebotomy counts as clinical hours, and the answer is a resounding yes. Phlebotomy is an essential part of healthcare and a great way to prepare for med school.
Pros of Phlebotomy:
Provides direct patient care and insight into diagnostics.
Accepted by medical schools as clinical experience.
Offers hands-on learning in an important area of patient care.
Cons of Phlebotomy:
Physically demanding and emotionally challenging.
The repetitive nature of the job may become monotonous over time.
Medical Scribing: A Valuable Experience for Premeds
Another excellent choice for premed students is medical scribing. As a medical scribe, you’ll work closely with doctors by documenting patient visits, learning medical terminology, and observing medical procedures. This role gives you an up-close look at the medical profession while helping you develop critical skills such as communication, medical ethics, and patient interaction.
Being a medical scribe counts toward medical school experience, as it provides exposure to the clinical environment, medical terminology, and the overall workflow of a healthcare team. Working as a scribe allows you to gain valuable experience and demonstrate your commitment to a career in medicine. If you’re wondering, "Does being a medical scribe help with med school?" the answer is yes. This role can significantly enhance your med school application by showcasing your ability to work in a clinical setting.
CNA: A Stepping-Stone to Healthcare Careers
While the role of a certified nursing assistant (CNA) offers valuable experience in the healthcare system, it may not be the best fit for premed students. CNAs provide direct patient care, assist with daily activities, and monitor patient conditions. While it offers hands-on experience, the scope of a CNA’s responsibilities is more focused on care rather than clinical decision-making, which is more aligned with the roles of a phlebotomist or scribe. Still, it provides essential patient care experience, and for those who may want to pursue nursing, being a CNA can be a good stepping stone.
Many premed students ask, "Does being a CNA look good for med school?" While it may not be as aligned with the prerequisites of medical school as other roles, it still offers strong clinical exposure and shows your commitment to patient care.
Phlebotomist vs CNA: Which Is Better for Med School?
When comparing phlebotomists and CNAs, phlebotomy is generally a better choice for premed students due to its alignment with clinical hours required for med school. While CNAs gain valuable patient care experience, phlebotomists are more involved in diagnostic tasks, which are directly related to medical practice. If you’re wondering, "Is it worth being a phlebotomist?" the answer is yes, particularly if you want to gain clinical experience that will look great on your med school applications.
Do Your Research Before Making a Decision
Before making a decision, it’s crucial to research the roles available to you. Each of these healthcare positions offers unique experiences that will shape your path toward med school. Whether you’re considering becoming a phlebotomist, medical scribe, or CNA, take the time to explore each role’s responsibilities and how they align with your goals. Speaking with mentors or professionals in the field can provide valuable insights into each of these careers.
Additionally, consider talking to someone already working in the medical field. Their firsthand experience can give you a better understanding of what each role entails and how it fits with your long-term goals. For example, speaking with current scribes or physicians can help you get a better sense of what the role of a medical scribe is really like.
Enroll in a Medical Scribe Certification Program
If you’re eager to take the next step, consider enrolling in a medical scribe certification program. These programs can provide you with the skills and knowledge necessary to excel in the role and prepare you for a career in the medical field. With certification programs available through reputable organizations, you’ll gain the expertise required for medical documentation and patient care, which will help you stand out when applying to medical school.
Less-Known Facts About Premed Clinical Roles:
Phlebotomy experience can lead to better opportunities in diagnostic labs—as phlebotomists often have opportunities to move into more specialized lab roles.
Medical scribing offers exposure to a wide variety of medical specialties, giving you a chance to see the day-to-day of different fields of medicine.
CNA experience can help build your empathy and understanding of patient care—skills that are invaluable as a future doctor.
Some medical scribe certification programs offer online courses, making it easier to pursue the certification without disrupting your premed schedule.
Phlebotomy can improve your fine motor skills, which are essential for many medical procedures.
Medical scribing roles are often available in telemedicine, giving premed students a chance to work in the rapidly growing field of virtual healthcare.
Conclusion
In conclusion, as a premed student, each role—whether as a phlebotomist, medical scribe, or CNA—offers unique advantages and opportunities for gaining valuable clinical experience. Phlebotomy provides essential diagnostic experience and is widely recognized by medical schools. Medical scribing gives you deep exposure to medical terminology, patient care, and the inner workings of a healthcare team, making it an excellent choice for building your med school application. While being a CNA offers solid patient care experience, it may be more suited for those pursuing nursing careers rather than medicine.
FAQs About Premed Roles:
-
Yes, phlebotomy is widely accepted as clinical experience by medical schools.
-
Yes, it provides exposure to clinical environments and demonstrates your commitment to healthcare.
-
While it provides valuable patient care experience, it may not be as directly aligned with med school requirements compared to other roles.
-
Phlebotomy is generally a better choice for premed students due to its direct involvement in diagnostics and clinical experience.
-
You can enroll in a medical scribe certification program offered by reputable organizations that will train you in medical documentation and patient care.